Sunday, June 7, 2020

Progress Against Antibiotic-resistant Bacteria


A dual-mechanism antibiotic kills Gram-negative bacteria and avoids drug resistance

From: Princeton University


June 3, 2020 -- Poison is lethal all on its own -- as are arrows -- but their combination is greater than the sum of their parts. A weapon that simultaneously attacks from within and without can take down even the strongest opponents, from E. coli to MRSA (methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus).

A team of Princeton researchers reported today in the journal Cell that they have found a compound, SCH-79797, that can simultaneously puncture bacterial walls and destroy folate within their cells -- while being immune to antibiotic resistance.


Bacterial infections come in two flavors -- Gram-positive and Gram-negative -- named for the scientist who discovered how to distinguish them. The key difference is that Gram-negative bacteria are armored with an outer layer that shrugs off most antibiotics. In fact, no new classes of Gram-negative-killing drugs have come to market in nearly 30 years.


"This is the first antibiotic that can target Gram-positives and Gram-negatives without resistance," said Zemer Gitai, Princeton's Edwin Grant Conklin Professor of Biology and the senior author on the paper. "From a 'Why it's useful' perspective, that's the crux. But what we're most excited about as scientists is something we've discovered about how this antibiotic works -- attacking via two different mechanisms within one molecule -- that we are hoping is generalizable, leading to better antibiotics -- and new types of antibiotics -- in the future."


The greatest weakness of antibiotics is that bacteria evolve quickly to resist them, but the Princeton team found that even with extraordinary effort, they were unable to generate any resistance to this compound. "This is really promising, which is why we call the compound's derivatives 'Irresistin,'" Gitai said.


It's the holy grail of antibiotics research: an antibiotic that is effective against diseases and immune to resistance while being safe in humans (unlike rubbing alcohol or bleach, which are irresistibly fatal to human cells and bacterial cells alike).


For an antibiotics researcher, this is like discovering the formula to convert lead to gold, or riding a unicorn -- something everyone wants but no one really believes exists, said James Martin, a 2019 Ph.D. graduate who spent most of his graduate career working on this compound. "My first challenge was convincing the lab that it was true," he said.


But irresistibility is a double-edged sword. Typical antibiotics research involves finding a molecule that can kill bacteria, breeding multiple generations until the bacteria evolve resistance to it, looking at how exactly that resistance operates, and using that to reverse-engineer how the molecule works in the first place.


They also tried using it against bacterial species that are known for their antibiotic resistance, including Neisseria gonorrhoeae, which is on the top 5 list of urgent threats published by the Center for Disease Control and Prevention.


"Gonorrhea poses a huge problem with respect to multidrug resistance," said Gitai. "We've run out of drugs for gonorrhea. With most common infections, the old-school generic drugs still work. When I got strep throat two years ago, I was given penicillin-G -- the penicillin discovered in 1928! But for N. gonorrhoeae, the standard strains that are circulating on college campuses are super drug resistant. 
What used to be the last line of defense, the break-glass-in-case-of-emergency drug for Neisseria, is now the front-line standard of care, and there really is no break-glass backup anymore. That's why this one is a particularly important and exciting one that we could cure."


The researchers even got a sample of the most resistant strain of N. gonorrhoeae from the vaults of the World Health Organization -- a strain that is resistant to every known antibiotic -- and "Joe showed that our guy still killed this strain," Gitai said, referring to Joseph Sheehan, a co-first-author on the paper and the lab manager for the Gitai Lab. "We're pretty excited about that."


The poison-tipped arrow


Without resistance to reverse engineer from, the researchers spent years trying to determine how the molecule kills bacteria, using a huge array of approaches, from classical techniques that have been around since the discovery of penicillin through to cutting-edge technology.

Martin called it the "everything but the kitchen sink" approach, and it eventually revealed that SCH-79797 uses two distinct mechanisms within one molecule, like an arrow coated in poison.


"The arrow has to be sharp to get the poison in, but the poison has to kill on its own, too," said Benjamin Bratton, an associate research scholar in molecular biology and a lecturer in the Lewis Sigler Institute for Integrative Genomics, who is the other co-first-author.


The arrow targets the outer membrane -- piercing through even the thick armor of Gram-negative bacteria -- while the poison shreds folate, a fundamental building block of RNA and DNA. The researchers were surprised to discover that the two mechanisms operate synergistically, combining into more than a sum of their parts.


"If you just take those two halves -- there are commercially available drugs that can attack either of those two pathways -- and you just dump them into the same pot, that doesn't kill as effectively as our molecule, which has them joined together on the same body," Bratton said.


There was one problem: The original SCH-79797 killed human cells and bacterial cells at roughly similar levels, meaning that as a medicine, it ran the risk of killing the patient before it killed the infection. The derivative Irresistin-16 fixed that. It is nearly 1,000 times more potent against bacteria than human cells, making it a promising antibiotic. As a final confirmation, the researchers 
demonstrated that they could use Irresistin-16 to cure mice infected with N. gonorrhoeae.


New hope


This poisoned arrow paradigm could revolutionize antibiotic development, said KC Huang, a professor of bioengineering and of microbiology and immunology at Stanford University who was not involved in this research.


"The thing that can't be overstated is that antibiotic research has stalled over a period of many decades," Huang said. "It's rare to find a scientific field which is so well studied and yet so in need of a jolt of new energy."


The poisoned arrow, the synergy between two mechanisms of attacking bacteria, "can provide exactly that," said Huang, who was a postdoctoral researcher at Princeton from 2004 to 2008. "This compound is already so useful by itself, but also, people can start designing new compounds that are inspired by this. That's what has made this work so exciting."


In particular, each of the two mechanisms -- the arrow and the poison -- target processes that are present in both bacteria and in mammalian cells. Folate is vital to mammals (which is why pregnant women are told to take folic acid), and of course both bacteria and mammalian cells have membranes. "This gives us a lot of hope, because there's a whole class of targets that people have largely neglected because they thought, 'Oh, I can't target that, because then I would just kill the human as well,'" Gitai said.


"A study like this says that we can go back and revisit what we thought were the limitations on our development of new antibiotics," Huang said. "From a societal point of view, it's fantastic to have new hope for the future."


Story Source:


Materials provided by Princeton University. Original written by Liz Fuller-Wright. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.


https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/06/200603132541.htm

Saturday, June 6, 2020

COVID-19 Can Last for Months

The disease’s “long-haulers” have endured relentless waves of debilitating symptoms—and disbelief from doctors and friends.


There is a harrowing article in The Atlantic about patients who endure the “mild” form of the virus for months.  See: https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/06/covid-19-coronavirus-longterm-symptoms-months/612679/

Friday, June 5, 2020

Coming: A Protein Synthesis Revolution


Large peptides can be made in hours, not days


Kira Welter has written an article for Chemistry World, the publication of the Royal Society of Chemistry, explaining how polypeptide chains can be created that are larger and much faster to create than through the use of current methods.



“….Although the expansion of the genetic code has made it possible to incorporate some unnatural units into proteins, the flexibility offered by chemical approaches is peerless. To make synthetic proteins, chemists rely on solid phase peptide synthesis, which involves building a peptide chain, one amino acid at a time, on a polymer resin. But this approach can only produce peptides up to 50 amino acids long, so several fragments must be created and stitched together to obtain proteins. This makes the approach time-consuming and laborious.

“Researchers working with Bradley Pentelute at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, US, have overcome this limitation using a flow reactor. Their new automated chemical protocol has allowed them to prepare peptides up to 164 amino acids long in hours – something that would take several days of synthesising and then stitching together smaller peptides using conventional techniques. ‘Before, we couldn’t make long sequences, we could only make peptides,’ Pentelute says. ‘Now, we can make a protein on the machine, and that’s the result of optimising the chemistry.’
More at:  https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/protein-synthesis-revolution-on-way-as-large-peptides-made-in-hours-not-days/4011891.article

Thursday, June 4, 2020

Earth's "Cleanest Air" Identified


An area above the Southern Ocean is unscarred by human activity.

From: Cosmos


June 4, 2020 – Cosmos, published by the Royal Institute of Australia, contains this article about aerosol research into what appears to be the cleanest and purest air in the world.

“The Southern Ocean is the place to breathe deep, it seems.

“Atmospheric scientists say they have identified a region south of 40 degrees latitude that is “truly pristine” because the boundary layer air that feeds the lower clouds is essentially free from aerosols produced by anthropogenic activities or transported from distant lands.

“The summer airborne bacterial community in this region, directly south of Australia, is dominated by marine bacteria emitted in sea spray, they say.

“The study – the first to measure the ocean’s bioaerosol composition – was led by Sonia Kreidenweis from Colorado State University in the US and used data collected on board the Australian research ship R/V Investigator.

“The findings are published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

“We were able to use the bacteria in the air over the Southern Ocean [SO] as a diagnostic tool to infer key properties of the lower atmosphere; for example, that the aerosols controlling the properties of SO clouds are strongly linked to ocean biological processes, and that Antarctica appears to be isolated from southward dispersal of microorganisms and nutrient deposition from southern continents,” says co-author Thomas Hill.”


https://cosmosmagazine.com/earth/earth-sciences/scientists-identify-the-cleanest-air-on-earth/

Wednesday, June 3, 2020

Coronavirus Likely a Hybrid Virus

Pieces of several genomes recombined to produce the pandemic-causing pathogen.

By John Timmer


Ars Technica – June 1, 2020 -- One of the longest-running questions about this pandemic is a simple one: where did it come from? How did a virus that had seemingly never infected a human before make a sudden appearance in our species, equipped with what it needed to sweep from China through the globe in a matter of months?


Analysis of the virus's genome was ambiguous. Some analyses placed its origin within the local bat population. Others highlighted similarities to pangolins, which might have been brought to the area by the wildlife trade. Less evidence-based ideas included an escape from a research lab or a misplaced bioweapon. Now, a US-based research team has done a detailed analysis of a large collection of viral genomes, and it finds that evolution pieced together the virus from multiple parts—most from bats, but with a key contribution from pangolins.


Recombination


How do pieces of virus from different species end up being mashed together? The underlying biology is a uniquely viral twist on a common biological process: recombination.


In cells, recombination is a normal part of genetics. Any time two DNA molecules share extensive similarities, it's possible for them to exchange pieces. The result is a hybrid molecule: a stretch of DNA from one parental piece of DNA, followed by a stretch from the other. As a result, some of the differences between the two parent molecules get scrambled—some from each parent will end up on the final molecule.


Recombination is a normal part of the reproduction of complicated cells. If you happen to have an offspring, you've given that child a set of chromosomes that are a mix of pieces from the ones you were given by your mother and father. Recombination can also take place in simpler cells, where it has been the primary tool that we've used to engineer new or altered genes into the genome of bacteria. And, since the molecules that perform the recombination aren't especially picky about which DNA molecules they work with, DNA viruses that infect cells can sometimes recombine if more than one strain of virus infects a single cell.


RNA


Those of you who have followed the virus closely, however, may be wondering what's going on here. All of this recombination takes place between DNA molecules. But the coronavirus genome is composed of RNA. So why would any of it work there?


The answer is that it doesn't. But other processes essentially perform the same function, mixing up pieces of RNA to form distinct genetic combinations. For example, the influenza virus spreads its genome across eight different molecules, allowing cells infected by more than one strain of flu virus to produce viral particles that have a random assortment of molecules from the two strains.


Coronavirus's genome is a single, long RNA molecule, so that sort of recombination doesn't work there. But it still can recombine. The enzyme that copies the RNA genome moves down it from one end to the other, making a copy as it goes. Sometimes, however, it can stall and fall off the molecule it's copying, while still hanging on to its partially complete copy. In many cases, the copying will just be aborted. But in others, it can latch on to a new genome and use the copy to pick up where it left off.


Critically, the new molecule with which it restarts the copying doesn't have to be the one it was copying originally. It just has to be similar to the first one it copied—it doesn't have to be identical. As a result, this process can allow recombination among viruses that are relatively distantly related from an evolutionary perspective. All they have to do is infect the same host.


Swapping genes


Now that we know recombination can take place, how would we go about looking for it? The key here is that we now have a lot of coronavirus sequences from a lot of different hosts available in public databases. Dedicated public health researchers have even gone in and sampled dozens of bat sources to look for strains that might be capable of starting a pandemic. So, for the new analysis, the research team started with a collection of 43 different coronaviruses from a variety of species, including humans, bats, and the pangolin sequences known to be similar to SARS-CoV-2.


The basic genome analysis confirmed that SARS-CoV-2 is most closely related to a number of viruses that had been isolated from bats. But different areas of the virus were more or less related to different bat viruses. In other words, you'd see a long stretch of RNA that's most similar to one virus from bats, but it would then switch suddenly to look most similar to a different bat virus.


This sort of pattern is exactly what you'd expect from recombination, where the switch between two different molecules would cause a sudden change in the sequence at the point where the exchange took place. (You'd see this rather than differences from both parent molecules being spread evenly throughout the genome.)


Spike protein


But there was a notable exception to this mixing of bat viruses: the spike protein that sits on the virus's surface and latches on to human cells. Here, the researchers found exactly what the earlier studies had suggested: a key stretch of the spike protein, the one that determines which proteins on human cells it interacts with, came from a pangolin version of the virus through recombination.


In other words, both of the ideas from earlier work were right. SARS-CoV-2 is most closely related to bat viruses and most closely related to pangolin viruses. It just depends on where in the genome you look.


The other bit of information to come out of this study is an indication of where changes in the virus's proteins are tolerated. This inability to tolerate changes in an area of the genome tends to be an indication that the protein encoded by that part of the genome has an essential function. The researchers identified a number of these, one of which is the part of the spike protein that came from the pangolin virus. Of all 6,400 of the SARS-CoV-2 genomes isolated during the pandemic, only eight from a single cluster of cases had any changes in this region. So, it's looking likely that the pangolin sequence is essential for the virus's ability to target humans.


Worrying evidence


There's some good news in all of this: rumors about this being an escaped weapons experiment make little sense in terms of what the genome sequences tell us about biology. Less reassuring, however, is what the sequences tell us about the giant natural experiment that may be going on around us. And that tells us there appears to be a large number of coronaviruses that are regularly exchanging genetic information. And, while exchanges are more common among viruses that infect the same species, it's entirely possible that contributions can come from much more distantly related ones.


The authors find evidence that the viruses from different species may experience distinct selective pressure, which isn't really surprising. But that also can produce difficult-to-predict results when those viruses hop to a new species—and the difficulty will rise if they then exchange information with other viruses native to that species.


Summing this up, there seem to be myriad coronaviruses out there (including plenty we don't know about), and some species are serving as labs in which new genetic combinations are created. And, right now, we only have a very partial window into the sort of potential out there in species that have frequent contacts with humans. And some research cited by the authors suggests that humans have been exposed to at least some of these viruses (based on antibodies to them)—fortunately without a major outbreak occurring.


All of which suggests that additional pandemics are a question of when, rather than if. But, of course, that had already been suggested in the aftermath of MERS and the original SARS, and the world as a whole did remarkably little to study the risk, work toward treatments, or plan for the pandemic's arrival. We can only hope that the more obvious example of COVID-19 will change that.

Science Advances, 2019. DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.abb9153  (About DOIs).


https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/06/sars-cov-2-looks-like-a-hybrid-of-viruses-from-two-different-species/



John Timmer became Ars Technica’s science editor in 2007 after spending 15 years doing biology research at places like Berkeley and Cornell.

Tuesday, June 2, 2020

Science Is Broken


By 1913intel


Please take a look at some short clips (articles further below) in order to get a broad view of the problems in science:


  • "relentless pursuit of taxpayer funding has eliminated curiosity, basic competence, and scientific integrity in many fields."
  • "physics, economics, psychology, medicine, and geology are unable to explain over 90 percent of what we see"
  • "climate, demography, asset prices, and natural disasters—are minimally predictable."
  • "chronic inability to reproduce research findings."
  • "progress in developing better theory and forecasting capability has stagnated since the 1960s."
  • There is a "replication and reproducibility crisis."
  • “’Nutrition’ is now a degenerating research paradigm in which scientifically illiterate methods, meaningless data, and consensus-driven censorship dominate the empirical landscape.”
  • "These dubious practices may include misrepresentations, research bias, and inaccurate interpretations of data."
  • "when a superstar scientist dies their field sees a small burst of activity in the form of fresh publications." These are highly cited. The superstar was hindering new ideas.
  • "There’s an increasing concern among scholars that, in many areas of science, famous published results tend to be impossible to reproduce."
  • "What is going on here? In two words: “communal reinforcement,” more commonly known as group-think."
  • "Another big project has found that only half of [psychology] studies can be repeated."
  • "But what about economics? Experimental econ is akin to psychology, and has similar issues."
  • "the whole academic discipline of economics is being re-considered: the theory as well as the policy advice."
  • "I’m suddenly concerned that all of published math is wrong because mathematicians are not checking the details, and I’ve seen them wrong before,". Because math builds on itself and is increasingly too difficult to check properly.



My experiences at four research universities and as a National Institutes of Health (NIH) research fellow taught me that the relentless pursuit of taxpayer funding has eliminated curiosity, basic competence, and scientific integrity in many fields. Yet, more importantly, training in “science” is now tantamount to grant-writing and learning how to obtain funding. Organized skepticism, critical thinking, and methodological rigor, if present at all, are afterthoughts. Thus, our nation’s institutions no longer perform their role as Eisenhower’s fountainhead of free ideas and discovery. Instead, American universities often produce corrupt, incompetent, or scientifically meaningless research that endangers the public, confounds public policy, and diminishes our nation’s preparedness to meet future challenges.



Mounting evidence suggests a lot of published research is false.



Scholarly research is in crisis, and four issues highlight its dimensions.


The first is that important disciplines such as physics, economics, psychology, medicine, and geology are unable to explain over 90 percent of what we see: dark matter dominates their theoretical understanding. ...


The second dimension of the research crisis is that systems which are critical to humankind—especially climate, demography, asset prices, and natural disasters—are minimally predictable. ...


The third dimension is a chronic inability to reproduce research findings. ...


The final indicator of crisis in research is that progress in developing better theory and forecasting capability has stagnated since the 1960s. ...


A new report released this week by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine is weighing in on a contentious debate within the science world: the idea that scientific research is fundamentally flawed, rife with published findings that often can’t be reproduced or replicated by other scientists, otherwise known as the replication and reproducibility crisis.



So which is it? Is the egg good or bad? And, while we are on the subject, when so much of what we are told about diet, health, and weight loss is inconsistent and contradictory, can we believe any of it? Quite frankly, probably not. Nutrition research tends to be unreliable because nearly all of it is based on observational studies, which are imprecise, have no controls, and don’t follow an experimental method. As nutrition-research critics Edward Archer and Carl Lavie have put it, “’Nutrition’ is now a degenerating research paradigm in which scientifically illiterate methods, meaningless data, and consensus-driven censorship dominate the empirical landscape.”



These dubious practices may include misrepresentations, research bias, and inaccurate interpretations of data. One common questionable research practice entails formulating a hypothesis after the research is done in order to claim a successful premise. Another highly questionable practice that can shape research is ghost-authoring by representatives of the pharmaceutical industry and other for-profit fields. Still another is gifting co-authorship to unqualified but powerful individuals who can advance one’s career. Such practices can unfairly bolster a scientist’s reputation and increase the likelihood of getting the work published. 



Years later, at a national meeting of scientists to set future research policy, I got a horrible shock. There was the fraudulent academic. They hadn’t been sacked; they had been promoted and invited to give their views on the future of research on a level footing with myself and other colleagues who I greatly respect. I was flabbergasted.How dis this happen? My strong suspicion is that the academic’s university had no desire for an inquiry that might risk damaging their reputation, given their failure to prevent his wrongdoing. I now regret not making a formal complaint for malpractice at the time, which would have forced them to take action. 



There’s a reason everyone’s confused about whether coffee causes cancer, or whether butter’s good for you or bad. Food research has some big problems, as we’ve discussed here and here: questionable data,  untrustworthy results, and pervasive bias (and not just on the part of Big Food). There’s reason to hope that scientists and academic journals will clean up their acts, and that journalists will refine their bullshit detectors and stop writing breathlessly about new nutrition “discoveries” that are anything but.  Until that happens, though, we all need to get better at filtering for ourselves.



In recent years, psychology has dealt with a legitimacy crisis. Many influential psychological studies could not be reproduced by other psychologists, discrediting some key insights and weakening academic faith in the entire field. Nutrition science has a similar problem. The loudest critics argue that the methodologies relied on by researchers give bad data that are meaningless at best. Others worry that funding gives undue influence to the federal government, big business, or influential nonprofit associations. And some critics think nutrition science focuses on the wrong questions entirely about nutrition.



Older scientists aren’t notably worse at accepting revolutionary ideas compared to younger colleagues, research has found. But a paper published in August in the American Economic Review suggests there may be subtler ways in which the top dogs have a discouraging effect on new entrants. According to the paper, which draws on decades of data on more than 12,000 elite biology researchers, when a superstar scientist dies their field sees a small burst of activity in the form of fresh publications. What’s more, the authors of the new papers, which are more likely than usual to be highly cited, are typically newcomers who have never published in this subfield before.



So, let’s imagine what might happen if the rules of professional science evolved such that scientists were incentivized to publish as many papers as they could and if those who published many papers of poor scientific rigor were rewarded over those who published fewer papers of higher rigor? What would happen if scientists weren’t rewarded for the long-term reproducibility and rigor of their findings, but rather became a factory that produced and published highly exciting and innovative new discoveries, and then other scientists and companies spent resources on the follow up studies and took all the risk?



The case against p-values and statistical significance is not a criticism of the concepts themselves but of their misuse.



Should we believe the headline, “Drinking four cups of coffee daily lowers risk of death”? How about, “Mouthwash May Trigger Diabetes. . .”? Should we really eat more, not less, fat? And what should we make of data that suggest people with spouses live longer?

These sorts of conclusions, from supposedly scientific studies, seem to vary from month to month, leading to ever-shifting “expert” recommendations. However, most of their admonitions are based on flawed research that produces results worthy of daytime TV.


Misleading research is costly to society directly because much of it is supported by the federal government, and indirectly, when it gives rise to unwise, harmful public policy.

Social science studies are notorious offenders. A landmark study in the journal Nature Human Behaviour in August reported the results of efforts to replicate 21 social science studies published in the prestigious journals Nature and Science between 2010 and 2015.  


The multi-national team actually “conducted high-powered replications of the 21 experimental social science studies — using sample sizes around five times larger than the original sample sizes” and found that “62% of the replications show an effect in the same direction as the original studies.” One out of the four Nature papers and seven of the seventeen Science papers evaluated did not replicate, a shocking result for two prestigious scientific journals. The authors noted two kinds of flaws in the original studies: false positives and inflated effect sizes.


Science is supposed to be self-correcting. Smart editors. Peer review. Competition from other labs. But when we see that university research claims – published in the crème de la crème of scientific journals, no less -- are so often wrong, there must be systematic problems. One of them is outright fraud – “advocacy research” that has methodological flaws or intentionally misinterprets the results. 



There’s an increasing concern among scholars that, in many areas of science, famous published results tend to be impossible to reproduce. This crisis can be severe. For example, in 2011, Bayer HealthCare reviewed 67 in-house projects and found that they could replicate less than 25 percent. Furthermore, over two-thirds of the projects had major inconsistencies. More recently, in November, an investigation of 28 major psychology papers found that only half could be replicated.Similar findings are reported across other fields, including medicine and economics. These striking results put the credibility of all scientists in deep trouble.



The latest in a raft of experiments suggests a predicted “train wreck” in social sciences is under way. Paul Biegler reports.“The findings reinforce the roles that two inherent intuitions play in scientific decision-making: our drive to create a coherent narrative from new data regardless of its quality or relevance, and our inclination to seek patterns in data whether they exist or not,” he says.Dingledine also says the results speak to a bigger problem, something Kahneman famously described in an open letter to colleagues in 2012 as a “train wreck looming”: the widespread failure to replicate the findings of many important studies in the social sciences.That wreck may well be upon us.A recent article in the journal Nature Human Behaviour reported an attempt to replicate 21 social science experiments published in the journals Nature and Science between 2010 and 2015. One study, for example, found that viewing images of Rodin’s sculpture The Thinker led people to think more analytically and discouraged a belief in God. It fell at the replication hurdle. In fact, the researchers only succeeded in 13 replications, and even then effect sizes were, on average, just half of those seen in the original experiments.



What is going on here? In two words: “communal reinforcement,” more commonly known as group-think. The headlines may say “research shows” but it doesn’t: researchers show. Scientists, like all of us, are affected by their peers’ opinions. If everyone does it, they think it’s probably ok. They also like to be liked, not to mention that they like having an income. This biases their judgement, but the current organization of the academic system does not offer protection. Instead, it makes the problem worse by rewarding those who work on popular topics. 



There is increasing concern that most current published research findings are false. The probability that a research claim is true may depend on study power and bias, the number of other studies on the same question, and, importantly, the ratio of true to no relationships among the relationships probed in each scientific field. In this framework, a research finding is less likely to be true when the studies conducted in a field are smaller; when effect sizes are smaller; when there is a greater number and lesser preselection of tested relationships; where there is greater flexibility in designs, definitions, outcomes, and analytical modes; when there is greater financial and other interest and prejudice; and when more teams are involved in a scientific field in chase of statistical significance. Simulations show that for most study designs and settings, it is more likely for a research claim to be false than true. Moreover, for many current scientific fields, claimed research findings may often be simply accurate measures of the prevailing bias. In this essay, I discuss the implications of these problems for the conduct and interpretation of research.



Another big project has found that only half of studies can be repeated. And this time, the usual explanations fall flat. Over the past few years, an international team of almost 200 psychologists has been trying to repeat a set of previously published experiments from its field, to see if it can get the same results. Despite its best efforts, the project, called Many Labs 2, has only succeeded in 14 out of 28 cases. Six years ago, that might have been shocking. Now it comes as expected (if still somewhat disturbing) news.In recent years, it has become painfully clear that psychology is facing a “reproducibility crisis,” in which even famous, long-established phenomena—the stuff of textbooks and TED Talks—might not be real. There’s social priming, where subliminal exposures can influence our behavior. And ego depletion, the idea that we have a limited supply of willpower that can be exhausted. And the facial-feedback hypothesis, which simply says that smiling makes us feel happier.



By now, most people have heard of the replication crisis in psychology. When researchers try to recreate the experiments that led to published findings, only slightly more than half of the results tend to turn out the same as before. Biology and medicine are probably riddled with similar issues. ...

But what about economics? Experimental econ is akin to psychology, and has similar issues....

This strongly suggests that there is a lot of mystery meat that goes into economists’ analysis. Scholars may add or remove different control variables, cut up their data into different slices, add or delete data, or modify their statistical analyses in a number of subtle ways. Any one of these can change the results.



But there is something else going on as well: the whole academic discipline of economics is being re-considered: the theory as well as the policy advice. Not all economists are on board with this project, and not all economics is being overthrown. And not all the rethinking is actually new. But it does seem that we are in the midst of a slow paradigm shift. Who knows where it will end?



"I think there is a non-zero chance that some of our great castles are built on sand," he said, arguing that we must begin to rely on AI to verify proofs.

Kevin Buzzard, a number theorist and professor of pure mathematics at Imperial College London, believes that it is time to create a new area of mathematics dedicated to the computerization of proofs. The greatest proofs have become so complex that practically no human on earth can understand all of their details, let alone verify them. He fears that many proofs widely considered to be true are wrong. Help is needed. ... New proofs by professional mathematicians tend to rely on a whole host of prior results that have already been published and understood. But Buzzard says there are many cases where the prior proofs used to build new proofs are clearly not understood. For example, there are notable papers that openly cite unpublished work. This worries Buzzard. “I’m suddenly concerned that all of published math is wrong because mathematicians are not checking the details, and I’ve seen them wrong before,” Buzzard told Motherboard while he was attending the 10th Interactive Theorem Proving conference in Portland, Oregon, where he gave the opening talk.



Academic journals in Russia are retracting more than 800 papers following a probe into unethical publication practices by a commission appointed by the Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS). The moves come in the wake of several other queries suggesting the vast Russian scientific literature is riddled with plagiarism, self-plagiarism, and so-called gift authorship, in which academics become a co-author without having contributed any work. The loudest critics argue that the methodologies relied on by researchers give bad data that are meaningless at best. Others worry that funding gives undue influence to the federal government, big business, or influential nonprofit associations. And some critics think nutrition science focuses on the wrong questions entirely about nutrition.


                  https://old.reddit.com/r/EmergingRisks/comments/ewt6i1/science_is_broken/

Monday, June 1, 2020

The Intelligence of Birds


                       The difficulty of defining or measuring intelligence in non-human animals makes the subject difficult to study scientifically in birds. In general, birds have relatively large brains compared to their head size. The visual and auditory senses are well developed in most species, though the tactile and olfactory senses are well realized only in a few groups. Birds communicate using visual signals as well as through the use of calls and song. The testing of intelligence in birds is therefore usually based on studying responses to sensory stimuli.


The corvids (ravens, crows, jays, magpies, etc.) and psittacines (parrots, macaws, and cockatoos) are often considered the most intelligent birds, and among the most intelligent animals in general; pigeons, finches, domestic fowl, and birds of prey have also been common subjects of intelligence studies.

Bird intelligence has been studied through several attributes and abilities. Many of these studies have been on birds such as quail, domestic fowl, and pigeons kept under captive conditions. It has, however, been noted that field studies have been limited, unlike those of the apes. Birds in the crow family (corvids) as well as parrots (psittacines) have been shown to live socially, have long developmental periods, and possess large forebrains, all of which have been hypothesized to allow for greater cognitive abilities.

Counting has traditionally been considered an ability that shows intelligence. Anecdotal evidence from the 1960s has suggested that crows can count up to 3. Researchers need to be cautious, however, and ensure that birds are not merely demonstrating the ability to subitize, or count a small number of items quickly. Some studies have suggested that crows may indeed have a true numerical ability. It has been shown that parrots can count up to 6, and crows can count up to 8.

Cormorants used by Chinese fishermen were given every eighth fish as a reward, and found to be able to keep count up to 7. E.H. Hoh wrote in Natural History magazine:

In the 1970s, on the Li River, Pamela Egremont observed fishermen who allowed the birds to eat every eighth fish they caught. Writing in the Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, she reported that, once their quota of seven fish was filled, the birds "stubbornly refuse to move again until their neck ring is loosened. They ignore an order to dive and even resist a rough push or a knock, sitting glum and motionless on their perches." Meanwhile, other birds that had not filled their quotas continued to catch fish as usual. "One is forced to conclude that these highly intelligent birds can count up to seven," she wrote.

Many birds are also able to detect changes in the number of eggs in their nest and brood. Parasitic cuckoos are often known to remove one of the host eggs before laying their own.

                       https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_intellige1nce