First published in the mid 1960s, How Children Fail began
an education reform movement that continues today. In his 1982 edition, John
Holt added new insights into how children investigate the world, into the
perennial problems of classroom learning, grading, testing, and into the role
of the trust and authority in every learning situation. His understanding of
children, the clarity of his thought, and his deep affection for children have
made both How Children Fail and its companion volume, How Children Learn,
enduring classics.
By Maria Morales on April 24, 2000
--Amazon.com
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Customer Review
4 Stars
Facing Our DemonsBy Maria Morales on April 24, 2000
This
book with its simple format and language has opened my eyes to possibilities
and perspectives that I simply never thought of. As an educator, I think
everyone in the world of education should read. From policy-makers to
administrators to teachers to school psychologists, and very specially,
parents, we all owe it to our children and to ourselves to become informed and
critical about the efficiency (or the lack thereof) of our educational system.
Especially at times, such as now, when our children seem to be failing more
than ever. Holt's observations, although limited to private schools, provide one
with a solid view of what is happening in the world of teaching accross the
board. Holt makes and answers questions that are not only relevant to his
subject but vital to the development of better teaching. Holt's idea that we
don't know enough about student-teacher relationships could not be more
accurate. I know this because I am an educator. I agree with Holt when he says
that it is time that we look beyond ourselves and our own interest and begin
looking at students with respect. As an insider, I couldn't help blushing while
reading the reasons that Holt gives for children's failure in school. I was
only able to nod my head positively when he said that teachers aren't listening
to their students because they are only listening to what they want to hear.
Another reason children fail, according to Holt, is that they are not being
intellectually challenged enough at school. The conclusion made by Holt makes
plenty of sense. Teachers definitely need to make every effort to free their
teaching from ambiguity, confusion and self-contradiction. Besides teachers,
the pointing finger also points to standardized exams. Standardized exams, I
agree with the author, do not make our children more knowledgeable. Holt's
final verdict is clear and pungent: Students are failing because
adults-teachers, administrators, parents, policy-makers, etc.-are not doing
their jobs. Although not a pleasant thing to hear (especially for those of us
who have chosen to dedicate our lives to the education of our young), I am
personally grateful to Mr. Holt for taking a bold stand to face us with our
demons.
No comments:
Post a Comment