The Passion of the Western Mind: Understanding the Ideas that Have Shaped Our World View
A book published on March 16, 1993
by Richard Tarnas
April 27, 2013
December 19, 2015
5 out of 5 stars – delicious prose
March 19, 2010
A book published on March 16, 1993
by Richard Tarnas
"The most lucid and concise
presentation I have read, of the grand lines of what every student should know
about the history of Western thought. The writing is elegant and carries the
reader with the momentum of a novel... It is really a noble performance."
--Joseph Campbell,
author of The Hero with a Thousand Faces
author of The Hero with a Thousand Faces
Here are the great minds of Western civilization and their
pivotal ideas, from Plato to Hegel, from Augustine to Nietzsche, from
Copernicus to Freud. Richard Tarnas performs the near-miracle of describing
profound philosophical concepts simply but without simplifying them. Ten years
in the making and already hailed as a classic, THE PASSION OF THE WESTERN MIND
is truly a complete liberal education in a single volume.
Amazon.com Customer Reviews
Review by Stephanie P.
5 out of 5 stars – Excellent book for class April 27, 2013
I bought this book as a requirement for one of my classes.
At first reading about the book and skimming through it before school started I
was very hesitant and already hated it. It seemed difficult to read and I could
not imagine reading the whole thing in a semester.
Once I got into my class however, my teacher took the book very slow and discussed everything in detail. He had such a passion for this book that it was hard not to fall in love with it as well. It was difficult to get into at first. Even after I got into it I still had some trouble following. But I have never been more involved in any book I've read before. When first starting I had to have a dictionary beside me and look up a lot of words. Towards the middle I had caught on to most of the language Tarnas used. I filled the pages with notes in the margins, and thoughts about what was discussed. None of my other text books look like that. I unfortunately did not get time to finish this in class, but with how excellent it has been so far I do not intend to ever sell this and continue reading it over the summer.
A word of advice for anyone else having to read this for school: take it slow, reread everything until you understand it, and have a dictionary ready. Or if you have a kindle get the kindle version and use the dictionary on there. But don't give up on the book so quickly. It really is a gem that I am glad I had the opportunity to read.
Once I got into my class however, my teacher took the book very slow and discussed everything in detail. He had such a passion for this book that it was hard not to fall in love with it as well. It was difficult to get into at first. Even after I got into it I still had some trouble following. But I have never been more involved in any book I've read before. When first starting I had to have a dictionary beside me and look up a lot of words. Towards the middle I had caught on to most of the language Tarnas used. I filled the pages with notes in the margins, and thoughts about what was discussed. None of my other text books look like that. I unfortunately did not get time to finish this in class, but with how excellent it has been so far I do not intend to ever sell this and continue reading it over the summer.
A word of advice for anyone else having to read this for school: take it slow, reread everything until you understand it, and have a dictionary ready. Or if you have a kindle get the kindle version and use the dictionary on there. But don't give up on the book so quickly. It really is a gem that I am glad I had the opportunity to read.
Review
by Paul A. Baier
5 out of 5 stars -- Skeptical at first, but read it cover to
cover and took notesDecember 19, 2015
This Herculean book is an important and valuable effort of
the collective Western mind over the last 2,500 [years]. The immense amount of
material is manageable because of Tarnas' superb writing. His summary of
different philosophical views from Socrates to post-modernism is excellent,
similar in a sense to Will Durant's book "The Story of Philosophy,"
where the reader feels like she gets an unbiased summary. He has strong views
about what happens after the current postmodern crisis and one may find his
Epilogue to be a bit much. I was left wondering about the Eastern Mind - does
it go through the same the evolutionary stages toward archetypal awareness,
and, if not, why not? My copy has underlines on nearly every page and I have
gone back and written summary notes. I recommend this book. Professor Tarnas,
nice work
5 out of 5 stars – delicious prose
March 19, 2010
Many readers that find disagreement with Jungian
psychoanalysis and various things falling under the rubric of "New
Age" have been turned off by this wonderful book. The diligent author
really did do such an "excellent job gathering information, seasoning it
with something mystical and cooking it with humanism"(as one reviewer
below comically and aptly puts it)! And it is also from my perspective
unfortunate he served as the final entree "the half-backed idea of a
'feminist rebirth'". This book might be spoiled for many thoughtful
readers due to author Richard Tarnas bringing anti-enlightenment views to bare
on our passionate intellectual history. But this book is so delightfully well
written the prose goes down like a crème brûlée prepared by a master chef. So
granted the author's spin is in the wrong direction, I still enjoyed this trip
through intellectual history very much even if it may be cause for possible
indigestion. I'd advise the prospective reader that you don't have to savor
every taste, much less swallow everything you are served, to still enjoy such a
well prepared feast for the intellect. I devoured most of this meaty, content
stuffed book-especially savoring the portions on "postmodernism" and
Existentialism. And Romanticism. One blurb among the several thousand included
in the first pages of the book is correct in it's claim that the summary of
postmodernism is worth the price alone. The dish on the Greeks was superb and
latter in the evening I still even had room for Hegel which went down surprisingly
well. 4.5 star meal for the mind, using the Amazon rating system, not a mere 1.
No comments:
Post a Comment