Determination is a positive emotional feeling that
involves persevering towards a difficult goal in spite of obstacles.
Determination occurs prior to goal attainment and serves to motivate behavior
that will help achieve one’s goal. Empirical research suggests that people
consider determination to be an emotion; in other words, determination is not
just a cognitive state, but rather an affective state. In the psychology
literature, researchers have studied determination under other terms, including
challenge and anticipatory enthusiasm; this may explain one reason for the
relative lack of research on determination compared to other positive emotions.
In the field of psychology, emotion research is heavily focused on negative emotions and the action tendencies that they encourage. However, recent work in positive psychology incorporates the study of determination as a positive emotion that pushes individuals toward action and results in important outcomes such as perseverance and the development of coping mechanisms
Emotions researchers continue to search for specific physiological patterns associated with discrete positive emotions; however, the frequent blending of emotions makes drawing such distinctions difficult. In relation to challenge and determination, psychologists have concluded it is best to focus on physiological activation in relation to the individual’s intended actions (what he/she is determined to do) rather than how the individual subjectively feels.
Researchers associate effort (action tendency) with challenge and determination; thus, a challenged/determined individual should experience physiological arousal that reflects effort. By focusing on the sympathetic nervous system (SNS), systolic blood pressure (SBP) can be used to measure activation that subsequently indicates increased effort. This means that, individuals who are introduced to a challenging task will experience an increase in SBP when they become determined to complete said task. Furthermore, this increased cardiac output is coupled with lowered total peripheral resistance; meaning, while the heart is pumping faster, the vasculature is relaxed. This finding displays an important distinction between the physiological reaction of an individual motivated by challenge and one motivated by threat or fear. Ultimately, there seems to be a specific physiological pattern associated with determination. The identification of said pattern is valuable as it may be used in research aimed at eliciting and studying the antecedents and consequences of this common positive emotion
Research using direct brain stimulation showed that electrical stimulation to the anterior midcingulate cortex elicits a response that mirrors the emotional experience of determination. In this case study of two epileptic seizure patients, participants reported feeling determined to overcome an approaching challenge; this emotion was reported to feel pleasant, rather than unpleasant. Following electrical stimulation, participants exhibited elevated cardiovascular activity and reported a warm feeling in their upper chest and neck. This work supports the idea that determination is a positive emotion that prepares an individual to overcome obstacles.
Another study compared determination and pride to see how these two positive emotions differentially influenced perseverance in the context of a mathematical problem-solving task. Using a directed imagery task in which participants listened to and imagined a particular scenario, emotion was differentially induced in participants. The results suggested that determination enhanced task engagement and perseverance, with participants in this group spending significantly more time on the most difficult problem in the task.
In contrast, pride decreased task engagement and perseverance relative to a neutral condition, with participants in this group spending significantly less time on the most difficult problem in the task. This research further supports the notion that determination motivates perseverance, perhaps more so than other positive emotions that have been theorized to be associated with perseverance.
In the field of psychology, emotion research is heavily focused on negative emotions and the action tendencies that they encourage. However, recent work in positive psychology incorporates the study of determination as a positive emotion that pushes individuals toward action and results in important outcomes such as perseverance and the development of coping mechanisms
Self-Determination Theory
Self-determination
theory (SDT) is a theory of motivation and dedication towards our ambition. SDT
focuses on the interplay between individual personalities and experiences in
social contexts that results in motivations of the autonomous and controlled
kind. Ultimately, social environments seem to have a profound effect on both
intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and self-regulation. More specifically,
self-determination theory proposes that social and cultural factors influence
an individual’s sense of personal volition and initiative in regards to goals,
performance and well-being. High levels of determination and personal volition
are supported by conditions that foster autonomy (e.g., individual has multiple
options/choices), competence (e.g., positive feedback) and relatedness (e.g.,
stable connection to the group an individual is working within).
Bio-Psychosocial Model
Emotions researchers continue to search for specific physiological patterns associated with discrete positive emotions; however, the frequent blending of emotions makes drawing such distinctions difficult. In relation to challenge and determination, psychologists have concluded it is best to focus on physiological activation in relation to the individual’s intended actions (what he/she is determined to do) rather than how the individual subjectively feels.
Researchers associate effort (action tendency) with challenge and determination; thus, a challenged/determined individual should experience physiological arousal that reflects effort. By focusing on the sympathetic nervous system (SNS), systolic blood pressure (SBP) can be used to measure activation that subsequently indicates increased effort. This means that, individuals who are introduced to a challenging task will experience an increase in SBP when they become determined to complete said task. Furthermore, this increased cardiac output is coupled with lowered total peripheral resistance; meaning, while the heart is pumping faster, the vasculature is relaxed. This finding displays an important distinction between the physiological reaction of an individual motivated by challenge and one motivated by threat or fear. Ultimately, there seems to be a specific physiological pattern associated with determination. The identification of said pattern is valuable as it may be used in research aimed at eliciting and studying the antecedents and consequences of this common positive emotion
Appraisal Theory
Appraisal theory
proposes that determination has three cognitive appraisal components. These
appraisals are evaluations of how the environment and situational circumstances
interact with aspects of the individual to create meaning and influence
emotional experience. In particular, experiences of determination are evoked by
appraisals of motivational relevance, which refers to whether a situation is
relevant to an individual’s commitments and goals; motivational incongruence,
which refers to whether a situation is incongruent with an individual’s
commitments and goals; and high problem-focused coping potential, which refers
to whether a situation is evaluated to be one that an individual can deal with
by using active coping strategies such as planning and problem-solving. These
appraisal components combine to bring on experiences of determination that then
motivate the tendency to persevere and strive towards mastery. In accordance
with this behavioral tendency, appraisal theory proposes that determination is
associated with effortful optimism, referring to the belief that a situation
can be improved upon with enough effort from the individual.
Empirical Findings –
Emotional Experience
Research using direct brain stimulation showed that electrical stimulation to the anterior midcingulate cortex elicits a response that mirrors the emotional experience of determination. In this case study of two epileptic seizure patients, participants reported feeling determined to overcome an approaching challenge; this emotion was reported to feel pleasant, rather than unpleasant. Following electrical stimulation, participants exhibited elevated cardiovascular activity and reported a warm feeling in their upper chest and neck. This work supports the idea that determination is a positive emotion that prepares an individual to overcome obstacles.
Another study compared determination and pride to see how these two positive emotions differentially influenced perseverance in the context of a mathematical problem-solving task. Using a directed imagery task in which participants listened to and imagined a particular scenario, emotion was differentially induced in participants. The results suggested that determination enhanced task engagement and perseverance, with participants in this group spending significantly more time on the most difficult problem in the task.
In contrast, pride decreased task engagement and perseverance relative to a neutral condition, with participants in this group spending significantly less time on the most difficult problem in the task. This research further supports the notion that determination motivates perseverance, perhaps more so than other positive emotions that have been theorized to be associated with perseverance.
Empirical Findings –
Emotional Expression
Experiences of
determination are linked to a recognizable facial expression that involves
frowning of the eyebrows, an expression that is perceptually similar to anger.
This eyebrow frown is associated with the perception of goal obstacles,
supporting the notion that determination is associated with the action tendency
of preparing to overcome difficult obstacles in goal pursuit.
No comments:
Post a Comment